Characters played by Kat Graham
Lauren
Characters played by Kendrick Sampson
Rob
Characters played by Jordan Claire Robbins
Zoe
Characters played by Miranda Edwards
Julia
Characters played by Sheryl Lee Ralph
Janet
Characters played by Kayla Heller
Paige
Characters played by Antonio Cayonne
Brian
Characters played by Shayn Walker
Mike
Characters played by Matt Hamilton
Logan
Characters played by Anita Brown
Rachel
Characters played by Eli Gabay
Nick
Characters played by Adam Thomas
Dave
Characters played by Gabriel Jacob-Cross
Shane
Characters played by Camille Kostek
Sam
Characters played by Daniel Boileau
Delivery Guy
Characters played by Laura Adkin
Cookie Employee
Characters played by Veronica Long
Singer
Characters played by Samantha Schimmer
Young Cupcake Worker
Characters played by Sarah Surh
Potential Shawl Buyer
Characters played by Jesse Miller
Bidder
Characters played by Nate Jester
Magician