Characters played by Beverly Banks
Kathy Lutz
Characters played by Wanda Cazabaun
Ethel Myers
Characters played by Rip Elliot
Photographer
Characters played by Jim Haniacek
Cameraman
Characters played by Larry Lemanski
Ronnie DeFeo Sr.
Characters played by Haley Manka
Dawn DeFeo
Characters played by Emerson Massaro
Missy
Characters played by Chris McCoy
Ronnie DeFeo Jr.
Characters played by Tyler Mercereau
George Lutz
Characters played by Dan Nachtrab
Narrator
Characters played by David Pozy
Hans Holzer & Priest
Characters played by Issac Taylor
Daniel