Characters played by Sterling Hurst
Kellen Newhall
Characters played by Jillian Armenante
Gloria
Characters played by Mark Atkinson
The Restaurant Manager
Characters played by Reiko Aylesworth
Regina Newhall
Characters played by Xander Berkeley
Priest James
Characters played by Alex Coppola
Server
Characters played by Aly Drummond
Mary Beth
Characters played by Meagen Fay
Susan Prescott
Characters played by Brian Gallagher
Stanley Prescott
Characters played by Michael Adam Hamilton
Officer Mulligan
Characters played by Erica LaRose
Jane
Characters played by Joel McHale
Greg
Characters played by Jessica Sipos
Olivia Prescott
Characters played by Connor Trinneer
Chief Sanders
Characters played by Alison Wachtler
Dr. Alice Baker
Characters played by Nickolas Wolf
Charlie