Characters played by Pamela Bass
Self - Former Neighbor
Characters played by Fred Berlin
Self - Forensic Psychologist
Characters played by Jerry Boyle
Self - Jeffrey's Defense Attorney
Characters played by Lionel Dahmer
Self - Jeffrey's Father
Characters played by Shari Dahmer
Self - Jeffrey's Stepmother
Characters played by Park Dietz
Self - Forensic Psychiatrist
Characters played by Nancy Glass
Self
Characters played by Cameron Guile
Jeffrey Dahmer
Characters played by E. Michael McCann
Self - Prosecutor
Characters played by Dennis Murphy
Self - Homicide Detective
Characters played by Owen Vitullo
Young Jeffrey Dahmer