Characters played by Melanie Stone
Ruby
Characters played by Ryan Carnes
Charlie
Characters played by Natasha Behnam
Philomena
Characters played by Cocoa Brown
Dean Latoya
Characters played by Siri Miller
Amber
Characters played by Richard Kind
Cupid
Characters played by Alia Shahid
Natalie
Characters played by Avery Sedlacek
Raif
Characters played by Meredith Lee McClure
Chloe
Characters played by Kelsey Rene
Samantha
Characters played by Cassandra Clare
Emily
Characters played by Carmen Burbridge
Gina
Characters played by Brandon Cameron
Ezra
Characters played by Drew Elhamalawy
Patrick
Characters played by Blayne Weaver
Fred
Characters played by Trevor Stevie Ray Ontiveros
Police Officer
Characters played by Rylie Butzbaugh-Patrick
Cupid's Receptionist
Characters played by Ali Dougherty
Jane
Characters played by Richard Colley
John
Characters played by Cherish McCormick
Leslie
Characters played by Rebecca Forrest
Marla
Characters played by Cassandra Rathie
January
Characters played by Elijah Immanuel
Skylar
Characters played by Alissa Cecalla
Waitress
Characters played by Dot Kelly
Lucy
Characters played by Kit Wilder
Carl
Characters played by Joshua Cody
Todd
Characters played by Samuel Cadieux
Choir Guy 1
Characters played by Jack B. Murphy
Choir Guy 2
Characters played by Caleb Rouse
Kyle
Characters played by Cameron Veach
Terry
Characters played by Chelsea Grace Fox
Charlie's Date
Characters played by Scott Spriggs
Cat Sweater Guy
Characters played by Jeremy Spring
Bar Guy