Characters played by Kenton Duty
Matt Prylek
Characters played by Danny Flaherty
Tommy Dolen
Characters played by Mary Beth Peil
'Gran' Angela Maria Tucci
Characters played by Katherine McNamara
Sarah O'Malley
Characters played by Kyle Dean Massey
Kyle Prylek
Characters played by Chris Riggi
Ned
Characters played by Jan Uczkowski
Philip King
Characters played by Tina Benko
Rhonda Sykes
Characters played by Raviv Ullman
Rip Barker
Characters played by Kelley Missal
Anya Bartosh
Characters played by Kent Moran
Coach Jay Nadley
Characters played by Talon G. Ackerman
Will Terkin
Characters played by Alex Boniello
Joe Grasso
Characters played by Owen Teague
Bobby Butler
Characters played by Jake Schwencke
Nate Quigley
Characters played by Megan Channell
Abby Peerson
Characters played by Morgan B. Ackerman
Lada Bartosh
Characters played by Dan Fabi
Dennis Wellingstone
Characters played by Joseph Harrington
Otto Tarkin
Characters played by Landon Harris
Lance Marston
Characters played by Christopher Rivera
Ty Hunter
Characters played by Robert Wuhl
Zack Conti
Characters played by Marc John Jefferies
Xav Foster
Characters played by Emily Taroli
Inna Bartosh
Characters played by Jane Aronson
Dr. Rita Wallace
Characters played by Patricia Santomasso
Mary Tucci Dolen
Characters played by Jonah Halperin
5-Year-Old Tommy
Characters played by Blake Costa
Chase O'Connor
Characters played by Linda Collins
Judge #1
Characters played by Kristen Michaud
Restaurant Server
Characters played by Elizabeth Wayman
Librarian
Characters played by Stan Babola
Pizzeria customer
Characters played by Erick Cuellar
Swim Team Bully
Characters played by Jaxon Ackerman
Young Matt