Characters played by Colton Underwood
Self
Characters played by Gus Kenworthy
Self
Characters played by Esera Tuaolo
Self
Characters played by Shelby Harris
Self
Characters played by Fran Drescher
Self
Characters played by Peter Marc Jacobson
Self
Characters played by Michael Sam
Self
Characters played by Cody Alan
Self
Characters played by Onyeka Ehie
Self
Characters played by David Kopay
Self