Characters played by Michael Raymond-James
Carter Jennings
Characters played by Samaire Armstrong
June O'Malley
Characters played by Timothy Omundson
Spencer Rabbit
Characters played by James Landry Hébert
Ofc. Jason Twitty
Characters played by Paul Rae
Commissioner Reid IV
Characters played by Lindsay Musil
Darla Mae Twitty
Characters played by Will Beinbrink
Reverend Jenks
Characters played by Lucky Johnson
Albert
Characters played by Mayra Leal
Caitlin Jackson
Characters played by Mark Chavarria
Gil
Characters played by Ryan Robertson
Mathis
Characters played by Barbara Weetman
Delores Oney
Characters played by Chad Lail
Rob
Characters played by Danny Epper
Thing One
Characters played by Judd Lormand
Mr. Freely