Characters played by David Coffin
Singing Fishman
Characters played by David Pridemore
Singing Fisherman
Characters played by Adam Wolf Mayerson
Singing Fisherman
Characters played by Mark S. Cartier
Singing Fisherman
Characters played by Meredith Holzman
Dee
Characters played by Ebon Moss-Bachrach
Gorski
Characters played by Sophie Lowe
Priscilla Connolly
Characters played by Morgan Saylor
Mary Beth Connolly
Characters played by June Squibb
Susie Gallagher
Characters played by Marceline Hugot
Doreen Burke
Characters played by Annette O'Toole
Gail Maguire
Characters played by Linda Shary
Mary Margaret Connolly
Characters played by Margo Martindale
Enid Nora Devlin
Characters played by Owen Burke
Paulie
Characters played by Skipp Sudduth
Officer Coletti
Characters played by Will Brittain
Officer Justin Brennan
Characters played by Gayle Rankin
Alexis
Characters played by Neil Odoms
Bob Gallagher
Characters played by Kendray Rodriguez
Beauty Shop Girl
Characters played by Mary Coombs
Bartender
Characters played by Kat Palardy
Tanya
Characters played by Thomas Kee
Declan Crawley