Characters played by Chris Messina
Jeremy Woods
Characters played by Tate Donovan
Robert McCarthy
Characters played by Trieste Kelly Dunn
Jennifer
Characters played by Luke Slattery
Eric
Characters played by Quinn Shephard
Abigail Grey
Characters played by Nadia Alexander
Melissa Bowman
Characters played by Geneva Carr
Mrs. Howell
Characters played by Tessa Albertson
Ellie Redgrave
Characters played by Owen Campbell
TJ
Characters played by Marcia DeBonis
Ms. Cohen
Characters played by Sarah Mezzanotte
Sophie Grant
Characters played by Larry Mitchell
Officer Dolan
Characters played by Michael Jefferson
Hallway Teacher
Characters played by Lily Houghton
Lily
Drama Student
Characters played by Whitney Harris
Melissa's mom