Characters played by Vinessa Shaw
Molly
Characters played by Tim Blake Nelson
Dennis
Characters played by Patrick Burleigh
Joel
Characters played by Tim Daly
Happy
Characters played by Amy Van Nostrand
Jodi
Characters played by Marsha Mason
Helen
Characters played by Edward Herrmann
Lloyd
Characters played by Michael C. Hall
Jonathan
Characters played by Charma Bonnanno
Customer #1
Characters played by Piper Goodeve
Jill
Characters played by Marissa McGowan
Bride
Characters played by Sam Daly
Kenny
Characters played by Joshua J. Masters
Groom
Characters played by Sam Lloyd Sr.
Old Man
Characters played by Jeffrey Dreisbach
Sheriff
Characters played by Katherine Valentine
Waitress
Characters played by Ari Graynor
Louise
Characters played by Sandra Gartner
Mother of the Groom
Characters played by Brian Shaw Jr.
Joel Lookalike