Characters played by J.R. Craig
Ken Whittiker
Private Investigator Ken Whittaker
Characters played by David Hill
BSO Homicide Detective
Sheriff Dwight McNeil
Characters played by Tasia Valenza
Narrator
Characters played by Shawn Thomas
Cop
Creepy Cop
Characters played by Randall Yarbrough
Gary Dunn
Characters played by Joshua Lee Young
Steve
Characters played by Nicole Laino
Cindy George
Characters played by C. Ronald McPherson
Father O'Brien
Characters played by Sarah Alami
Brenna Douglas
Characters played by Barbara Jean Barrielle
Helen Woolley
Characters played by Ben Beaune
Alex
Characters played by Leslie Birkland
Self
Characters played by John Butterfield
Sheriff Investigator
Characters played by Heather Ashley Chase
Beauty Contestant
Characters played by Hunter Clowdus
Ricky Rush
Characters played by Meléna Declan
Elizabeth Kenyon
Characters played by Lena Drake
Jackie Johns
Characters played by Jennifer Ann Elmore
June Thomson
Characters played by Rachael Fahlstrom
Rosario Gonzalez
Characters played by Malorie Felt
Dayna Spencer
Characters played by Katy Foley
Jeanne Johns
Characters played by Mandell Frazier
Larry Hazlett
Characters played by Jade Froeder
Nona Dirksmeyer
Characters played by Emily Green
Beauty Contestant
Characters played by Libertad Green
Beauty pageant contestant
Characters played by Casey Hanley
Kevin Jones
Characters played by Brian T. Hoffman
Investigation officer
Characters played by Krista Dane Hoffman
Tana Woolley
Characters played by Holly Houk
Pageant Announcer
Characters played by Ashley Jeffery
Gerald Carnaham
Characters played by Emily Jordan
Sheila Jo Harris
Characters played by Adeana Lane
Lisa
Characters played by Randy Lee
Russel Douglas
Characters played by David Light
Dub
Characters played by Lindsay McGrail
Officer Morgan
Characters played by Clancy McLain
Peggy Sue
Characters played by Michael Kennen Miller
Scott
Characters played by Shakira Ja'nai Paye
Curtisha Morning
Characters played by Elise Robson
Salon Girl
Characters played by Vlada Rykova
Pageant queen
Characters played by Tim Scanlon
Investigating Officer
Characters played by Wesley Scott
Earl
Characters played by Angela Solouki
Former pageant queen
Characters played by David John Walsh
Pageant Announcer
Characters played by Chase Wright
Cody Wright
Characters played by Greg Audino
Sonny
Characters played by Donnie Avants
Greg
Characters played by Joseph Aviel
John Zufina
Characters played by Maximus Birchmore
School Kid
Characters played by Tate Birchmore
School Boy
Characters played by Chandra Brenner
Julie
Characters played by Marcus David de la Fuente
Suspect
Characters played by Zack Dean
David Miller
Characters played by Johnny Rey Diaz
Joe
Characters played by Paul Damien Dios
Steven
Characters played by Nathaniel Dupree
Sergeant Sweeny
Characters played by Ron Franscell
Self - Narrator
Characters played by Mark Grossman
Rick
Characters played by Brendan Healey
Marcus
Characters played by Farley Jackson
Carl
Characters played by Ashley Johnson
Kalila Taylor
Characters played by Frederick Keeve
Ed George
Characters played by Wilfred Lopez
Pageant Host
Characters played by Vittorio Nuzzo
Police Officer
Characters played by Chuck Saale
Detective
Characters played by Annie Sims
Bar Patron
Characters played by Jessica Trainham
Irene
Characters played by David Ulmer
Detective Novatak
Characters played by Hilary Vetter
Tara
Characters played by Mark Vuncannon
Det. Schweers
Characters played by Wendie Weldon
Vicki
Characters played by Joseph Wilson
Bar Tender
Characters played by Carl Zauner
George
Characters played by Dean England
Officer McDaniel (2013)
Characters played by Charmaine Cleveland
Churchgoer
Characters played by Patrick Shea
Detective