Characters played by Madison Iseman
Pam
Characters played by Jeff Kober
Bruce
Characters played by Deirdre Lovejoy
Pastor Hodges
Characters played by Laura Bell Bundy
Lorraine
Characters played by Catherine Curtin
Ruth Ann
Characters played by Auden Thornton
Angie
Characters played by Ben Curtis
Billy
Characters played by Paten Hughes
Kaylee
Characters played by Wynn Reichert
Ray
Characters played by Schann Mobley
Dyer's Secretary
Characters played by Bridget Berger
Sophie
Characters played by Jon Arthur
Sheriff Stevens
Characters played by Allie Spetalnick
Geena
Characters played by Timothy Morton
Wyatt
Characters played by Radney Foster
Zachariah
Characters played by Mallory Hudson
Hostess
Characters played by Libby Barnes
Karen
Characters played by DonShea Stringer
Nigel
Characters played by Tom Morton
Dyer
Characters played by Makayla Jackson
Tasha
Characters played by Mike Schroerlucke
Inspector
Characters played by Kristina L. Ives
Terry
Characters played by Wylie Caudill
Guy in Gentleman's Club
Characters played by Jameson Fowler
Trey
Characters played by Matt Haeck
Bartender
Characters played by Takayla Williams
Maya