Characters played by Andy Samberg
Host
Various
Characters played by Akiva Schaffer
Host
Various
Characters played by Jorma Taccone
Host
Various
Characters played by Roxanne Arvizu
Fake Margi
Characters played by Jack Black
George Washington
Characters played by Sarah Chalke
Melissa
Characters played by Jeff Bryan Davis
The Cowboy
Characters played by Jonah Goldstein
Various
Characters played by Marielle Heller
Waitress
Characters played by Jessica Hoffman
Background Talent
Characters played by The Lonely Island
Themselves
Characters played by Phil Lord
Self
Characters played by Christopher Miller
Self
Characters played by Ramsey Moore
Shop Owner
Characters played by Kal Penn
Guy Reading Newspaper
Characters played by Chris Romano
Self
Characters played by Brandon Routh
Officer Dino Wong
Characters played by Margi Samberg
Self
Characters played by Patti Schaffer
Self
Characters played by Sue Ellen Taccone
Self
Characters played by Chester Tam
Various