Characters played by Candace Cameron Bure
Aurora Teagarden
Characters played by Lexa Doig
Sally Allison
Characters played by Marilu Henner
Aida Teagarden
Characters played by Bruce Dawson
John Queensland
Characters played by Peter Benson
Arthur Smith
Characters played by Sonya Salomaa
Marcia
Characters played by Dan Payne
Torrance
Characters played by Miranda Frigon
Lynn Liggett
Characters played by Stephen Huszar
Father Scott Aubrey
Characters played by David Ingram
Macon Turner
Characters played by Fiona Vroom
Carey Reilly
Characters played by Daniel Bacon
Lemaster Cane
Characters played by Barbara Wallace
Jane Engles
Characters played by Ellie Harvie
Lillian Tibbett
Characters played by Craig March
Captain Frederick Burns