Characters played by Candace Cameron Bure
Aurora Teagarden Miller
Characters played by Niall Matter
Nick Miller
Characters played by Lexa Doig
Sally Allison
Characters played by Peter Benson
Arthur Smith
Characters played by Dylan Sloane
Phillip
Characters played by Marilu Henner
Aida Teagarden
Characters played by Julia Benson
Lizzy Allison
Characters played by Natasha Bure
Teen Aurora Teagarden
Characters played by Ben Cotton
Reggie Harris
Characters played by Brad Harder
Sergeant Heard
Characters played by Mia Shanks
Teen Sally Allison
Characters played by Cole Vigue
Davis Mettle