Characters played by Lexi Lawson
Lucy
Characters played by Mark Ghanimé
Scott
Characters played by Beth Broderick
Carol
Characters played by Cardi Wong
Randall
Characters played by Adam Hurtig
Matt
Characters played by Ernie Pitts
Paul
Characters played by Sharon Bajer
Brenda
Characters played by Stephanie Sy
Rose
Characters played by Darren Felbel
Mayor Wilson
Characters played by Paul Essiembre
Greg
Characters played by Scarlett Smith
Young Lucy
Characters played by Tom Anniko
Hal
Characters played by Zoe Fish
Mae
Characters played by Daina Leitold
Angela
Characters played by Eric Blais
Terry
Characters played by Ava Darrach-Gagnon
Mary
Characters played by Elena Anciro
Joanna
Characters played by Hazel Venzon
Alison
Characters played by Steven Ratzlaff
Hank
Characters played by Kelley Hirst
Ellie
Characters played by Kevin Harris
Taxi Driver
Characters played by Jeremy Ferdman
Wade
Characters played by Frederick Allen
One of the three wise men
Characters played by Lorrie Papadopoulos
Townsfolk