Characters played by James McCaffrey
Edward Carnby
Characters played by John Cunningham
Theophile Paddington
Characters played by Alexandra Williamson
Sarah Flores
Characters played by Chris Phillips
Crowley
Characters played by Michael Cullen
Hermes Trysmegiste
Characters played by Adam Sietz
Lucifer
Characters played by Adrianne Rogers
Anna
Characters played by Chris McKinney
Guard Great Hall
Characters played by Jake Robards
Matthew
Characters played by Jason Griffith
Hammet Jack the Watchman
Characters played by Troy Hall
Scoff
Characters played by Matthew Piazzi
Dr. William Hartford
Characters played by Ed Moran
Sonny
Characters played by Neil Michael Goldberg
Additional Voices
Characters played by Steven Ogg
Vinnie (as Steve Ogg)
Characters played by Bill Lobley
Additional Voices
Characters played by Stephanie D'Abruzzo
Additional Voices
Characters played by Chris Peterson
Additional Voices
Characters played by Steven Cambria
Additional Voices
Characters played by Morgan Harris
Additional Voices
Characters played by Johanna Igel
Additional Voices
Characters played by Fey Gerbes
Additional Voices