Characters played by Paul Schneider
Paul
Characters played by Zooey Deschanel
Noel
Characters played by Shea Whigham
Tip
Characters played by Danny McBride
Bust-Ass
Characters played by Maurice Compte
Bo
Characters played by Heather McComb
Mary-Margaret
Characters played by Benjamin Mouton
Uncle Leland
Characters played by John Kirkland
Justin
Characters played by James Marshall Case
Judge Harvey
Characters played by Patricia Clarkson
Elvira
Characters played by Maya Ling Pruitt
Feng-Shui
Characters played by Eddie Rouse
Dancing Orderly
Characters played by Karey Williams
Tammy Clinard
Characters played by Matt Chapman
Strong Bad
Characters played by Amanda Chaney
Girl on the porch
Characters played by Maribeth Ayers
Noel's friend
Characters played by Summer Shelton
Noel's other friend
Characters played by Bob Hardison
Bob
Characters played by Bartow Church
Geoff Seibanick
Characters played by Rutledge
Dwayne
Characters played by Thunderbird Dinwiddie
Tonya
Characters played by Trista Michelle LaPrade
(uncredited)