Characters played by Robert Taylor
- Joel Shore
Characters played by Stewart Granger
- Mark Shore
Characters played by Ann Blyth
- Priscilla Holt
Characters played by Betta St. John
- Native Girl
Characters played by Keenan Wynn
- Silva
Characters played by James Whitmore
- Fetcher
Characters played by Kurt Kasznar
- Quint
Characters played by Lewis Stone
- Capt. Holt
Characters played by Robert Burton
- Asa Worthen
Characters played by Peter Whitney
- James Finch
Characters played by John Lupton
- Dick Morrell
Characters played by Jonathan Cott
- Carter
Characters played by Mitchell Lewis
- Cook
Characters played by James Bell
- Aaron Burnham
Characters played by Leo Gordon
- Peter How
Characters played by Michael Pate
- Varde
Characters played by Clancy Cooper
- Smith
Characters played by Frank DeKova
- Stevenson
Characters played by Henry Rowland
- Jones
Characters played by Stanley Andrews
- Matthew Shore's Father
Characters played by George Barrows
- Fighter in Mutiny
Characters played by Walter Coy
- Noah Shore
Characters played by Frankie Crane
- Native Crewman
Characters played by John Damler
- Second Mate
Characters played by James Davis
- Native Crewman
Characters played by John Doucette
- George
Characters played by Wesley Gale
- Native
Characters played by Harry Hines
- The Bartender
Characters played by Richard Karlan
- Sam
Characters played by Owen McGiveney
- Old Man at Bar
Characters played by Tyler McVey
- John Shore
Characters played by Vesey O'Davoren
- The Minister
Characters played by Alexander Pope
- Fat Man
Characters played by Keith Richards
- (uncredited)
Characters played by Morgan Roberts
- Black Sailor
Characters played by Glenn Strange
- Chanty Man
