Characters played by Peyton List
Aileen Wuornos
Characters played by Tobin Bell
Lewis Fell
Characters played by Lydia Hearst
Jennifer Fell
Characters played by Swen Temmel
Grady
Characters played by Andrew Biernat
Mitch
Characters played by Ashley Atwood
Older Aileen
Characters played by Lincoln Brown
Businessman
Characters played by Christa Collins
Sandy
Characters played by Christopher Corbin
Dewey
Characters played by William "Will" Daubert
Jail Guard
Characters played by Domenico Riso
Victim
Characters played by Joseph Schwartz
Keith Wuornos
Characters played by Ben Smith-Petersen
Hobie
Characters played by Leslie Stratton
Courtney
Characters played by Hamish Sturgeon
Peter
Characters played by Nick Vallelonga
Victor Miller
Characters played by Buz Wallick
Father MacReady
Characters played by Meadow Williams
Diane Pittman