Characters played by Zachary Quinto
Josh Norman
Characters played by Jenny Slate
Emily Milburton
Characters played by Sheila Vand
Hannah
Characters played by Jon Hamm
Craig
Characters played by Tonya Pinkins
Abigail
Characters played by Dale Soules
Lucille
Characters played by Marin Ireland
Jenny
Characters played by Peter Grosz
Anthony
Characters played by Jacinto Taras Riddick
Davenham
Characters played by Stephen Schnetzer
Don Herremans
Characters played by Noah Robbins
Daniel
Characters played by Alex Kramer
Rob
Characters played by Michael Oberholtzer
Brent
Characters played by James Joseph O'Neil
Husband
Characters played by Brigid Ryan
Wife
Characters played by Charlie Semine
Dad
Characters played by Ashley Williams
Monica Hartline
Characters played by Jack Lanyo
Young Josh
Characters played by Lauren Kroll
Debbie
Characters played by Brian Tweedy
(uncredited)