Characters played by Michael Benyaer
Marty
Characters played by Kerën Burkett
Holly's Mom
Characters played by Sharon Crandall
May
Characters played by Alia Domino
No-Brow Janet
Characters played by Aaron Douglas
Windmere
Characters played by Rachel Dratch
Marga
Characters played by Ana Gasteyer
Hildy
Characters played by Ken Godmere
Old Timey Doctor
Characters played by Nils Hognestad
Percy
Characters played by Amanda Huxtable
Redhead Mum
Characters played by Cheyenne Jackson
Frank
Characters played by Duane Keogh
Postman Steve
Characters played by Vella Lovell
Holly
Characters played by Pippa Mackie
Waiter (Cocoa Kiosk)
Characters played by Ella May
Townsfolk lady
Characters played by Ryan McPartlin
Chancington Winterthorpe V
Characters played by Aiyanna Miorin
Young Holly
Characters played by Brendan Riggs
NY Man
Characters played by Kwasi Thomas
Jackie
Characters played by Daylin Willis
Ty