Characters played by Emily Blake
Sweet
Xander (Walk Through Fire)
Characters played by Steven Brandon
Mustard Guy
Characters played by Erika Burke
Dawn (What You Feel)
Characters played by Chewie K. Darsow
Anya
Characters played by Rommy Cortez Driks
Tara (Walk Through Fire)
Characters played by Sarah J. Eagen
Dawn (Dawn's Lament)
Buffy
Characters played by Camille Falciola
Willow (I've Got a Theory)
Characters played by Gabriel Figueroa
Spike (Something to Sing About
Where Do We Go From Here)
Characters played by Mickey Fisher
Giles (Standing)
Characters played by Tal Fox
Anya (I've Got a Theory)
Characters played by Elle Goddard
Tara (Under Your Spell
Standing Reprise)
Characters played by Ellie Rebekah Goddard
Tara (Under Your Spell
Standing Reprise)
Characters played by Vera Goudie
Buffy (I've Got a Theory)
Characters played by Kristen Hodges
Anya (I'll Never Tell)
Characters played by Matthew Hodges
Xander (I'll Never Tell)
Characters played by Kire Horton
Sweet (What You Feel)
Characters played by Nathan Johston
Giles (Under Your Spell
Standing Reprise)
Characters played by Gray Jones
Giles (I've Got a Theory)
Characters played by Blythe Kala
Dawn (Dawn's Ballet)
Characters played by Haley Keim
Buffy (Going Through The Motions)
Characters played by Leah Kesselman
Anya (Walk Through Fire)
Characters played by Joseph Knauber
Spike (Coda)
Characters played by Greg Machlin
Giles (Walk Through Fire)
Characters played by Adam Mallinger
Sweet's Minion
Characters played by Jessica Moak
Pole Tapper
Characters played by Joe Anthony Myrick
Sweet (What You Feel Reprise)
Characters played by Omar Najam
Spike (Rest in Peacer)
Characters played by Alex Nicholson
Giles
Characters played by Stephanie Pressman
Dawn (Where Do We Go From Here)
Characters played by Jon Recher
Demon (Going Through The Motions)
Characters played by Brian Michael Scully
Xander
Characters played by Sade Sellers
Tara (Under Your Spell)
Characters played by Lee Shorten
Hot Victim Guy (Going Through The Motions)
Characters played by Katie Sikkema
Buffy (Coda)
Characters played by Riley Silverman
Willow (Walk Through Fire)
Characters played by Amy Sullivan
Dawn
Characters played by Don Swenson
Xander (I've Got a Theory)
Characters played by Kristina Westin
Anya (Where Do We Go From Here)
Characters played by Lindsay Zana
Buffy (Walk Through Fire)